i used to use pamperin because midol didn't do shit for me, but it's no longer available where I live and i've switched to maxidol. Pamperin didn't do much to kill the pain for me but it sure knocked me out. Compare Midol vs. Tylenol, which is better for uses like: Pain, Cramping and Headaches. Compare head-to-head ratings, side effects, warnings, dosages, interactions and patient reviews. Patients rated Midol 4.1/5 over Tylenol 3/5 in overall satisfaction. In the painkiller ranking, Tylenol Extra Strength performs better than Midol Complete Caplets. Find out why! La demie-vie d'un médicament est le temps que la moitié de la dose prescrite tarde en être éliminée totalement du corps ou du sang. Les médicaments avec une demie-vie plus courte prennent effet plus rapidement, cependant, il faut qu'on les consomme moins souvent que les autres Then I started taking Tylenol. Years later, Tylenol wasn't working. So I moved up to regular strength Midol. Years go by and it wasn't working. Both Motrin and Midol are well-known medications utilized for their ability to treat pain. Motrin is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) that is utilized to treat fever, aches and pains related to illness, headaches or toothaches. Doctors give trusted answers on uses, effects, side-effects, and cautions: Dr. Neuberg on midol vs motrin: However, always talk to your doctor before starting any new prescription or over-the-counter medication. Midol can provide relief from period symptoms including menstrual cramps, bloating, fatigue, headache, backache and muscle aches. I have taken so many midol and tried other things. but nothing seems to solve my problem. I THINK I know what you are going through. Except I cant tolerate pain.